Gov’t to introduce electronic voting to HSYK elections
The Justice Ministry is preparing to modify the composition of the controversial Supreme Board of Judges and Prosecutors (HSYK) as part of the judicial reform that is currently taking place with the purpose of ensuring greater harmony with European Union legislation. Under the new system, all judges and prosecutors will be able to vote in the election of the board members.
Justice Minister Sadullah Ergin on Saturday met with reporters at the İstanbul Judge House to discuss the emerging details about the Judicial Reform Strategy Action Plan. Noting that the legal amendments which will change the composition of the HSYK are the natural consequences of the EU-membership process, Ergin said parliaments are actively involved in the election of members of the HSYK-like boards in EU member countries.
Stressing that in addition to Parliament and the high courts, 12,000 judges and prosecutors working in the local courts may participate in the election process, he explained that the National Judiciary Network Project (UYAP) can be used as a medium for electronic voting for this purpose. Ergin further indicated that the judicial reform package does not consist only of amendments concerning the HSYK, but it will also contain major reforms to boost and improve judicial independence and impartiality.
He said the proposal to increase the number of the HSYK members to 21 in the Judicial Reform Strategy Action Plan has created some controversy. Pointing out that the proposed changes are part of the country’s EU bid, the justice minister explained that 12,000 judges working for courts, with the exception the Supreme Court of Appeals and the Council of State, will be able to participate in the election of the Board members.
He also pointed out that the 2007 report by the Venice Commission stressed the need for the election of the majority of the judicial board members by the judiciary and for the election of the remaining members by Parliament, a measure that will reinforce democratic legitimacy of the board. Ergin emphasized that they propose that Parliament should elect its quota from among jurists. He asserted that while it is important that judicial independence is preserved and that the judiciary is administered by its own members, the need for the accountability of the judiciary should not be ignored.
Referring to the Justice Ministry’s study on HSYK-like organizations in other countries, Ergin said in virtually all of these countries, Parliament and senior judges are involved in the election process. Ergin gave France (with an 18-member board), Italy (27 members), Spain (21 members), Poland, Belgium and the UK (25 members) as examples.
07 September 2009, Monday
TODAY’S ZAMAN İSTANBUL
http://todayszaman.com/tz-web/news-186361-101-govt-to-introduce-electronic-voting-to-hsyk-elections.html